gatnerd

Military Guns and Ammunition

Hosted by gatnerd

This is intended for people interested in the subject of military guns and their ammunition, with emphasis on automatic weapons.

  • 3361
    MEMBERS
  • 191271
    MESSAGES
  • 24
    POSTS TODAY

Discussions

NGSW Phase 2 Consolidation and info   Small Arms <20mm

Started 30/8/19 by gatnerd; 556535 views.
stancrist

From: stancrist

30/5/22

Guardsman26 said:

I think you have missed my point about the logistics of 6.5x48 mm Creedmoor ammunition versus the logistics of 6.8x51 mm NGSW. I estimate that the latter system will cost 30-40% more than 6.5x48 mm Creedmoor. 10% would be significant, but anything above 20% will kill NGSW.

And that would be bad, how?  

EmericD

From: EmericD

30/5/22

stancrist said:

The question was not about terminal effects at 600 meters.  The question was about the need to engage at 600 meters.

The need for infantry to "engage" at 600 m (or up) is mostly a byproduct of the Rules of Engagement, but even with liberal RoE, the infantry needs to fix the enemy.

EmericD

From: EmericD

30/5/22

renatohm said:

What if you resort to higher pressures, but not NGSW high?

What barrel length are you comfortable with?

SIG's 6.8x51 mm pressure seems to be the price to pay for a 13" barrel instead of 19", or a 16" barrel instead of 22".

stancrist

From: stancrist

30/5/22

EmericD said:

       stancrist said: The question was not about terminal effects at 600 meters.  The question was about the need to engage at 600 meters.

The need for infantry to "engage" at 600 m (or up) is mostly a byproduct of the Rules of Engagement, but even with liberal RoE, the infantry needs to fix the enemy.

Okay, but I'm not seeing how that answers either of Nick's questions:

"How important is the need to engage enemy targets at 600 metres?"

"How often will we need to engage enemies at this range?"

gatnerd

From: gatnerd

31/5/22

At the 12:45 we have FA testing of the SPEAR at 50yd; actually looks very good in terms of controllability and burst accuracy at that distance.

Sig MCX Spear - US Army NGSW - Disassembly, Live Fire & Discussion

InRange is entirely viewer supported:https://www.patreon.com/inrangeSpecial thanks to @illumined_arms for making this video possible! Please go check them o...

The 'flow-through' suppressor also seems to be working well; no gas to the shooters face, and pretty compact. 

stancrist

From: stancrist

31/5/22

gatnerd said:

FA testing of the SPEAR at 50yd; actually looks very good in terms of controllability and burst accuracy at that distance.

It does look pretty good.  Brass-cased (lower power) ammo, though -- not the full-power hybrid stuff.

gatnerd

From: gatnerd

31/5/22

Ah, great eye Stan. 

That brings up a pretty interesting feature; it seems like the Spear can fire both standard (62ish) pressure rounds, as well as the 80kpsi high pressure rounds. 

I wonder whether this requires changing the gas setting, and if there is a dedicated setting for both types of ammo? 

EmericD

From: EmericD

31/5/22

stancrist said:

Okay, but I'm not seeing how that answers either of Nick's questions: "How important is the need to engage enemy targets at 600 metres?" "How often will we need to engage enemies at this range?"

That just mean that depending on your RoE, engaging enemy targets at 600 m (or higher) could be rare and few (like during WWII & Korea), or up to one quarter (25%) of the infantry engagements (like Afghanistan).

That also mean that in the first case, issuing a DMR is probably sufficient to deal with those "rare & few" events, but in the second case you will probably need a NGSW.

gatnerd

From: gatnerd

31/5/22

EmericD said:

That also mean that in the first case, issuing a DMR is probably sufficient to deal with those "rare & few" events, but in the second case you will probably need a NGSW

Would a Full Power DMR & LMG paired with SCHV rifles be adequate for the 2nd scenario? 

For example NZ's configuration; 5.56 rifles (interestingly using 77gr) paired with a 7.62 DMR and 7.62 LMG:

To me, a similar configuration with NGSW seems better then a pure 5.56 or pure 6.8. 

6.8 LMG(s) and (optionally) 6.8 DMR, paired with 5.56 rifles for the rest. 

TOP