Big Four Sports

Hosted by MRCROSSROADS|Offsite Big Four Sports

Big Four Sports: NFL, NBA, NHL, MLB

  • 23
    MEMBERS
  • 56
    MESSAGES
  • 1
    POSTS TODAY

Discussions

Should Pete Rose be inducted into the HOF?   MLB General

Started Dec-26 by MRCROSSROADS; 210 views.
MRCROSSROADS

Poll Question From MRCROSSROADS

Dec-26

Should Pete Rose be inducted into the HOF?
  • Yes (Why?)9  votes
    75%
  • No (Why not?)3  votes
    25%
Yes (Why?) 
No (Why not?) 

I voted "yes" because in my opinion he's paid for his crime.  Sure, he messed up all those years ago.  Who among us hasn't made a colossal screw up?  I think he's paid for it though and to deny him his rightful place in the HOF is cruel and petty. 

MRCROSSROADS
Host

From: MRCROSSROADS 

Jan-1

I agree. He should be judged based on his performance. It's not like he was a PED junkie.

smilingeorge

From: smilingeorge 

Jan-1

He lied about it for decades. Then he only admitted to it cause he wrote a book and made money if it. He should never be allowed in the hall. Want to forgive a player let shoeless Joe into the hall. 

MRCROSSROADS
Host

From: MRCROSSROADS 

Jan-1

I have a bigger issue with him having sex with 16 year olds than I do him lying. But neither relate to on-field performance. Shoeless Joe intentionally throwing games does though.

Granted you Voice. Welcome!

smilingeorge

From: smilingeorge 

Jan-2

They halls opinion seems to be tha t betting on games while managing directly impacted the game. I agree with that. 

MRCROSSROADS
Host

From: MRCROSSROADS 

Jan-2

Me too. Anything he did as a manager should be disregarded. What he did as a player should stand on its own. 

How do you feel about known PED users being candidates?

In reply toRe: msg 1
MRCROSSROADS
Host

From: MRCROSSROADS 

Jan-2

Six for, 2 against so far.

smilingeorge

From: smilingeorge 

Jan-2

Non of them should get in. Ever. 

TOP