DFTBA (KansasMomO3)

Catholic Homeschooling

Hosted by DFTBA (KansasMomO3)

This forum is for Catholic homeschooling families to discuss challenges, successes, curriculum providers and anything else related to homeschooling. Non-Catholics are welcome.

  • 790
  • 24372
  • 0



And The Math Decision is Made...   Math & Science

Started 2/24/12 by Just Doin' My Best! (PACHIMAC); 79 views.
As a family, we have decided today that I am not the best teacher for Melissa where Mathematics is concerned.  I feel very sad about it.

We started out today and immediately got into attitude, sulkiness, purposely missing problems, not working - the whole shebang. I brought Mike in to have Melissa show him how she does division problems, and I sat in the back of the room while he worked with her.

He's amazing. He pulled things out of her that I couldn't dream of doing. He pulled out tricks and questions to get her to focus.

He explained to her about the right brain/left brain and how if she's worried or anxious, the Math side of her brain won't work. He kept calling her back to the logic.

He corrected her sloppy quick writing and how she was holding the pen.

He went over her times tables to find that she had NO IDEA that they had patterns to learn. She used her fingers or counted in the air. She has never memorized any of them. Apparently she wrote them on scratch papers then threw them away before I came back when she did her tests so that she didn't have to memorize them.

She has learned enough to pass tests, but she isn't retaining any of it. We have to go back to the beginning and start with the concepts of addition and subtraction. She will STILL try to subtract 8 from 1 and get the answer 7 in stead of borrowing from the 10's column. She still will write ones in the ten's column...I am starting to wonder now if she really understands the number place system as well. :(

She understands skip counting but doesn't realize that is what Multiplication is - regrouping to add faster with groups.

When dividing, she will slip between dividing, multiplying and adding instead of choosing which concept is the correct one.

I feel like a complete fool and a failure that I thought she understood the concepts, but because of my frustration with her, she's turned so emotional she can't do them anymore.

We are starting over again - drills on addition and subtraction facts. Drills on multiplication tables. Online math games to strengthen the times tables.

Kinda sucks because she WANTS to move on to fractions in the book, but I can't in good conscience let her do it when division is a big part of the understanding of fractions.

She is SO smart...too smart for her own good, I think. I thought she was understanding each part - and she was at the time, but her retention is very bad and her implementation of which property or operation to use to solve a problem is not there EXCEPT in word problems - which is strange. Those should be very hard for her.

So...I feel a little bit deflated today. I know as a parent I must do what is best for her, and what's best for her is for me to NOT teach her math...but I can't say I'm not feeling blue about it.

If anyone can point me to a really fun game to work with math facts, I'd REALLY appreciate it.
Dave is better about working with Jonathan...I so wish that he was home during the week.  Dave struggled with it himself and he is so much more patient than I am.
Just because she is having trouble with Math now, doesn't mean you are a bad mommy, or a bad teacher. And maybe at another time you will be able to teach her math. But it is ok not to be able to do it right now, or ever. And it is *great* that she gets math in the real world, the story problems. That is wonderful. It means she understands how math is used day to day, but in abstract it is confusing. And from a developmental point of view, that is understandable.  For my 2nd grader, he can only do subtraction with carrying if we get out the manipulative ever.single.time. I've been told by our counselor at STAA that kids don't usually have their multiplication math facts completely down until 5th or 6th grade. We keep struggling with it too. My 5th grader started doing really well with them, so we stopped doing the daily flashcards. Then they all leaked out of his brain. :( So we are back to it again. 

I have heard Timez Attack is good. I think that is the name. We have being using some Motion Math apps on the ipad for other concepts, and they have been very helpful. I think they have some addition stuff, some number line stuff, as well as fraction stuff. 

I hope things go a little better with your husband taking over Math. I am finding I have to have my husbands help to be able to keep the attitude in check, and get my oldest to do his stuff. My oldest does better when I am on hand to help out, but he reports to my husband each night what he accomplished. 

Just remember, he is "fresh" to the job. She will respond to him differently because it's new, and he is not already burnt out from previous encounters. Don't be too hard on yourself! ((hug))
I really like the flashcards that came with the Saxon math books.  They are color-coded and you work with one color at a time until those are mastered.  Something about knowing "all the green cards are x2" sort of sets the child's brain up for success.

Another thing I've done with my kids is to create "counting cards" out of index cards.  For instance, to learn the multiples of 3, you would write them out one per index card from 3 to 36 (or whatever).  Then the child takes the stack and counts the cards down as they  create a path with them along the floor.  They then pick the cards up from highest to lowest this time, saying out loud the number on each card as they pick it up.  Repeat 2 or 3 times per day (one set of multiples per day or week).

When all the multiplication facts are learned, my kids then drill with me and a timer daily (sometimes more than once/day).  I start the timer and then begin flipping the entire stack of flashcards.  They get rewards for beating their best time.

It is a lot of one-on-one work for the teacher/mom, but I don't think there is any method that works as well as flashcards for memorizing math facts.


From: Tara_SD


I think I posted about this before but I can't find it.

This blog is run by the head teacher of an Educate Together school here - they have a very child-centred ethos, teachers on a first-name basis etc. They are known for innovative tricks :). Rote learning just doesn't seem to happen in ET schools.

He wrote an 8-part series on multiplication - I think it's brilliant. Start at part 2, below. He makes it astoundingly simple.


Andrew was using the palms-up finger trick for a good while but now I find that he knows a lot of them without using it.

Good luck!