Politics & War -  Tariffs to 25% (3681 views) Notify me whenever anyone posts in this discussion.Subscribe
 
From: Paul (SNOTZALOT) DelphiPlus Member IconMay-7 1:33 PM 
To: gunter DelphiPlus Member Icon   (7 of 72) 
 2076.7 in reply to 2076.5 


Paul Krugman
Opinion Columnist

If you’re trying to understand why we may be on the brink of a full-scale trade war, with a huge expansion of U.S. tariffs on Chinese goods and, inevitably, Chinese retaliation, it may help to remember what happened a few weeks ago, while Notre Dame was burning.


As you may recall, Donald Trump decided to tell French firefighters how to do their job, tweeting that they should use “flying water tankers” to douse the flames. The French civil defense department responded with a tweet — in slightly fractured English — that didn’t mention Trump, but pointed out that water-bombing could cause the entire cathedral to collapse.


What does this have to do with trade? What the water-bombing incident shows us is that Trump has strong opinions on everything, even when he is completely ignorant of the subject. Fortunately, when it came to French firefighting, he couldn’t turn those opinions into action. Unfortunately, when it comes to trade policy, he can: U.S. trade law gives the president enormous discretionary authority to impose tariffs.


Trump’s tweets over the past few days may well be featured in future economics textbooks as perfect illustrations of how people misunderstand the basics of international trade and trade policy. In fact, I can pretty much guarantee it, since I’m the co-author of two textbooks.


First, Trump is still saying that because we run a $500 billion trade deficit with China — it’s actually $379 billion, but who’s counting? — that means we lose $500 billion. As some economists quickly pointed out, by this logic we all lose when we go shopping at our local supermarkets. After all, do the supermarkets buy anything from us in return? No!


Second, Trump keeps asserting that China is paying the tariffs he has already imposed. This could be true, if tariffs were driving Chinese prices down; in fact, the threat of more Chinese tariffs on U.S. agricultural exports is one reason grain prices have just plunged to a record low.But enough time has passed for economists to look at the actual results of Trump’s trade policy so far, and the Chinese are not, in fact, paying the tariffs. As I wrote a couple of months ago, “to a first approximation, foreigners paid none of the bill, U.S. companies and consumers paid all of it.”


So if you’re trying to make sense of what’s happening on trade, you should start with the basic point that Trump has no idea what he’s doing, that there isn’t any coherent U.S. policy goal.That still leaves the question of why what seemed to be a deal in the making may have fallen apart (or maybe not: this could all be theater.) Last week it looked as if China would mollify Trump by offering some “tweetable deliveries” — promises to buy U.S. products that would let him claim victory without leading to any substantive change in Chinese policy. Did the Chinese actually, as the administration claims, start to walk back some of their promises? Did a trade hard-liner get Trump’s ear? Did Trump hear that the likely deal would probably be panned by the news media? Nobody knows.


One thing is certain, however: If we do get into a full-scale trade war, for whatever reason, it will be very hard to end it, and the world economy will never be the same.

 

 


Disclaimer: All RAS/work procedures suggested in this forum are just that, suggestions. You are responsible for determining safe work procedures etc. No one in this forum is responsible for YOUR safety and any claims made against any member/moderator/manager of this forum are a waste of time. In other words, you lop off a finger and all you'll get is a letter of condolence from your attorney!

Mr. Sawdust Book!   Note, book link for forum members convenience, and a courtsey to Mr. Sawdust! (In other words, I don't sell the Mr.Sawdust Book and I don't make any money selling the Mr. Sawdust Book.)

How To Insert Images Into Your Post!

Best Regards,

Paul R.

 
 Reply   Options 

 
From: Paul (SNOTZALOT) DelphiPlus Member IconMay-7 1:52 PM 
To: gunter DelphiPlus Member Icon   (8 of 72) 
 2076.8 in reply to 2076.5 

Take a look at some of these charts today 05-07-2019

 

 
From: gunter DelphiPlus Member Icon May-7 5:18 PM 
To: Paul (SNOTZALOT) DelphiPlus Member Icon  (9 of 72) 
 2076.9 in reply to 2076.8 

Market is up! from the low of the day.

 

 
From: RGoss99May-8 11:22 AM 
To: Paul (SNOTZALOT) DelphiPlus Member Icon  (10 of 72) 
 2076.10 in reply to 2076.8 

Playing the market, is a complicated game which requires an understanding of all possible factors which change the numbers.

While in law, Trump´s tweets have no status, just self promotion for the eyes and ears of his base.

At the same time, even given Trump´s unpredictability, and lack of follow through a clever investor, can often anticipate negative results.

 

 
From: gunter DelphiPlus Member Icon May-8 6:47 PM 
To: RGoss99  (11 of 72) 
 2076.11 in reply to 2076.10 

hanging in there, trying to decide which way to go ...

 

 
From: gunter DelphiPlus Member Icon May-9 4:04 PM 
To: All  (12 of 72) 
 2076.12 in reply to 2076.11 

 

 
From: gunter DelphiPlus Member Icon May-9 4:20 PM 
To: All  (13 of 72) 
 2076.13 in reply to 2076.12 

Looking for a compromise.

 

 
From: gunter DelphiPlus Member Icon May-9 9:38 PM 
To: All  (14 of 72) 
 2076.14 in reply to 2076.13 

 

 
From: gunter DelphiPlus Member Icon May-9 9:46 PM 
To: All  (15 of 72) 
 2076.15 in reply to 2076.14 

 

 
From: gunter DelphiPlus Member Icon May-10 9:23 AM 
To: All  (16 of 72) 
 2076.16 in reply to 2076.15 

 

Navigate this discussion: 1-6 7-16 17-26 27-36 ... 47-56 57-66 67-72
Adjust text size:

Welcome, guest! Get more out of Delphi Forums by logging in.

New to Delphi Forums? You can log in with your Facebook, Twitter, or Google account or use the New Member Login option and log in with any email address.

Home | Help | Forums | Chat | Blogs | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service
© Delphi Forums LLC All rights reserved.