This is a place for friendly and civil discussion of horse racing of all types including handicapping.
Latest Nov-28 by smartyslew
Latest Nov-27 by SameSteve G
Latest Nov-24 by Wintertrian
Latest Nov-21 by SameSteve G
Latest Nov-20 by pianot
Latest Nov-15 by pianot
Latest Nov-14 by DogsUpWired
Latest Nov-12 by ChiefsCrown
Latest Nov-9 by TexSquared
Latest Nov-8 by TexSquared
Latest Nov-8 by RAESFAN
Latest Nov-5 by Wintertrian
Latest Nov-5 by Wintertrian
Latest 10/27/21 by DogsUp
Latest Nov-4 by princeofdoc
Latest Nov-1 by pianot
You're multi-talented, dogs. :)
Zildjians? They sound sweet.
Nothing like good cymbals, eh dogs.
Growing up I was a "whys" guy of epic proportions. My parents and teachers often pulled their hair out. I have this need to understand why certain things occur. Along those lines, I'm trying to understand why frontrunners have been doing particularly well in the 10f Kentucky Derby in recent years. Starting with California Chrome in 2014, no horse that crossed the line first in the Derby, was worse than 3rd at any point in the race. Before that, you have to go back to Smarty Jones in 2004.
Is it simply the Baffert effect, as most have come from his barn? Is it the breeding industry which has been incentivized by all that money for horses that can win the shorter races? Could it possibly something inadvertent that resulted from the changes in training methods? Horses are starting later and later, running fewer and fewer times. Closers do most of their running in the latter part of the race, so could the lighter racing affect the development of their foundation, relative to their frontrunning opponents that do a bit more heavy lifting throughout the course of a race, causing closers to have a diminished kick late? Remember when it became a thing that frontrunners began stealing Belmonts? Is this just a natural progression of the same trend?
I think this trend started 50 years ago when Bold Ruler was bred to Something Royal to give us Big Red.
that was the start of a so called speed horse bred to a Classic bred Mare and the Nasrullah, Princequillo
Nick. Some Deep pocket breeders caught on to that, others discovered Northern Dancer and
Native Dancer Ran/ Mr P for Dirt in North America, breeders many without deep pockets with Lasix breeding speed on speed. The rest of the world Europe and Japan and others Used Northern Dancer
To breed for Turf with great female nicks compatible to ND female tff 2d thru Almamoud in Europe family 5h tff like sadlers wells, and in Japan to Sunday Silence bred to Nor Dancer bmsires. Imo like Smarty Jones with the 13c and 1x, seattle slew 13c ,1x passed on to Api and other famlies like 23b,4m, 8c, 2s,
A4,8f spread in a 5 generation pedigree. Many of these families have BPT tff conduits that carry their speed over a distance of ground and have a balanced pedigree and the styles front runners and stalkers
seem to dominate like this year my top 5 fall in this group with one closer in the 5.At this point anyone can jump up in March or April and of course this is imo and I think it supports what Raes is saying in a different form.
I agree that pedigree is probably the biggest reason, but is there any merit to the theory that the changing trend relative to the preparation of these horses, is exacerbating the “problem”? Will it become a vicious cycle as people breed more and more to winners of these contests?
I don't know. There is evidence the Breeders in North America changed when the Derby Format
changed to have less sprinter milers, one turners getting in the mix, At least the deep pockets
I think they should limit the entrants for a trainer and give somebody else a chance for the Derby.
The Turf runners in America seems more balanced ,saying that the special feed and drugs have to go.
I'm sure over time you have heard someone knock a trainer, some of them are good horseman and take care of their horses and are not cheaters or suspected cheaters, even then we don't know the truth.
Soon we will have a 20 horse field of maidens at the rate we are going and changes are badly needed
and I don't think I will live to see it. have to have 2 races at 2, or one might be doable. 3 races at 3 before the Derby. nah that won't happen.