Interesting in relation to foundation.Personally,I think both are quality animals but this is too much too soon

Exactly, If Pletcher did his job he would tell his clients with Derby Fever to get another Trainer

and take the loss from his purse, and or enter at the next level race . 2 for 62 is crazy

3 or 4 a year 

I would prefer a conservative trainer.It’s like hiring a financial planner and ignoring his advice.Like you said,the trainer should put the horse first and tell their clients what is in the horses best interests

One for Shaddy. good luck  Edit Lasix Free 2nd Place Two Phils

Here is an angle to take a good look at, what do they have in common 
yes they all won a Gr race in last start, what else ?
all are Lasix free runners. Are you going to use a Horse
for the win whos highest speed number is with Lasix or
one from this group carrying 126 pounds at 10 furlongs
and you can add Mandarin Hero to this group L free
and missed the Win by a nose.
-----

Forte 1st Florida Derby won 5 gr races in a row
Practical Move 1st Santa Anita Derby won 3 gr races in a row
Two Phils 1st Jack Ruby Steaks AW 9f g3
Lord Miles 1st Wood 9f g2
Derma Sotogage 1st UAE Derby g2, 9 3/16 f
Confidence Game 1st Rebel G2  8,5fsly
---
4/12/23 12 entrants in the top 20 Point System are Lasix Free
5 others one race With L , check them out in the top 20.
--

25 derby contenders last race splits with last 1/8 for 9f preps and Last Q for all races
Historical  times are 25.40 or faster for Last Q, last 1/8  12.80 >, Runup for each race
Dubai runup is 0, Wood 88,Santa Anita 85, Ruby 80, Florida 70, Ark 60, Blue Grass 50, 5 entrants
Lexinton 50, Louisiana 45, (Sunland 20 (MTB)) 15 of 25 entrants  Last Q time is 25.40 or better
This Many is new for the 21st Century, we have had years with 4 or 5 . Tricky year for speed.
+ Kingsbarns Slowest Mile time 1st 20  39.13  with historic Final Q 24.31 and Lasix in last RAW TIME 9 3/16

-------------------------  start ---2f ------4f-------6f-------8f--------9f---last 1/8 ---last Q  ----------   Off L =Lasix in previous   

--------

Without 2 of the Japanese Colts on here ,3 from the Santa Anita Derby

2 on AW or turf and Forte and Practical Move 103 a new 3 yr old high 8.5f 1.41.3

3 back , this is the top tier to go over first looking for different styles and what

these numbers don't tell you is where I like to start pro and con. the first thing

that jumps out at me is why 3 from one race are they the Cream of the crop

Forte last 3 races are going in the wrong direction according to the speed numbers

the variant doesn't agree with that and bit by bit maybe better and watch replays

for all and in forte case to me looks like he hasn't been cut loose yet watch and decide

for your self. For Me this is where I start, Listening to others suggest I'm still in the starting Gate

5 Two Phils               98AW+11,78-6,82+1,69--,83+2
2 Practical Move        97+3,100--,103+11(8.5f)91-4,77-3, 2 races at 3
24 Mandorin Hero       97+3

23 Major Dude           93AW+6,94+2T,85+1T,81-6T
21 Skinner                 96+2,96--,95L+11,65-23,89-5,
1 Forte                     93+2,90+1,88-1,80--,90 +2, msw 91+6    6 races 2 at 3

Edit ; The track variant used is the DRF track variant.

Without 2 of the Japanese Colts on here ,3 from the Santa Anita Derby
2 on AW or turf and Forte and Practical Move 103 a new 3 yr old high 8.5f 1.41.3
3 back , this is the top tier to go over first looking for different styles and what
these numbers don't tell you is where I like to start pro and con. the first thing
that jumps out at me is why 3 from one race are they the Cream of the crop
Forte last 3 races are going in the wrong direction according to the speed numbers
the variant doesn't agree with that and bit by bit maybe better and watch replays
for all and in forte case to me looks like he hasn't been cut loose yet watch and decide
for your self. For Me this is where I start, Listening to others suggest I'm still in the starting Gate

5 Two Phils               98AW+11,78-6,82+1,69--,83+2
2 Practical Move        97+3,100--,103+11(8.5f)91-4,77-3, 2 races at 3
24 Mandorin Hero       97+3
23 Major Dude           93AW+6,94+2T,85+1T,81-6T
21 Skinner                 96+2,96--,95L+11,65-23,89-5,
1 Forte                     93+2,90+1,88-1,80--,90 +2, msw 91+6    6 races 2 at 3variant

--

This is similiar to your Angel  DI   CD

Last years Derby Winner Mandaloun :DP = 2-3-1-0-0 (6) DI = 11.00   CD = 1.17 has only 2 Chefs in the first 4 generations

with a Stam Chef in the 5th generation, and stamina Mares and Sires in the 6th generation Producing some Stamina in The 5th Generation

Not to many new Chefs in the last 7 or 8 years. We will be seeing a lot of this with the Chefs pushed back to the 5th 6th  generations.

Gerh said...

Interesting in relation to foundation.Personally,I think both are quality animals but this is too much too soon

Yes I prefer foundations for classic distance routers to be built slowly, and over time, by a patient trainer who is not looking to leap to the breeding shed at end of age 3.   Too much too soon is spot on. 

I want to see classic distance horses running at age 4, 5, 6, etc.   You can't do that if you don't build a foundation slowly, and certainly not when a very young, non-mature musculoskeletal system is still developing, at age 2-3.    I feel sorry for horses put thru The Baffert Program.    TBs aren't quarterhorses and shouldn't be trained like them. 

To that, some people will say to me "he is a trainer, you are not, and he's been successful doing it that way"

My answer is that there are many roads to success........some of them you don't have to take, and maybe shouldn't.  There are a myriad of roads to success, and you can choose the road that benefits the horses as well.  First, Do No Harm.